There are many connections that can be made between Life is Beautiful and Night by Elie Wiesel. One connection can be that obviously, both involved the Holocaust. Now, we all know that of course both these works have the Holocaust, but its more specifically how they're described that's different. Elie had faced the more brutal side of the Holocaust. While Guido, determined to keep his son away from the horrors of the Holocaust, says its all a game and tries to keep the humor for his kid throughout the movie. Another connection in between the movie and the book, was that both get their families separated. Again, Night showing us the more brutal side of the Holocaust, how Elie says that after his mother and sister went to the right, he never saw them again. In Life is Beautiful Guido and his wife do get separated, but he does everything in his power to show her that himself and their son are still alive and were well. For example when they snuck into the radio room and sent her a message while she was picking out clothes as her job. Or when he put on the song they had seen being preformed in an opera before the concentration camps.
In Life is Beautiful and Night by Elie Wiesel, there are also many scenes that are different and similar. A similarity is when the families, like mentioned earlier, are separated. In Night the family arrives at Birkenau and immediately guards are shouting at them to form lines. As Elie stated, "An SS came toward us wielding a club. He commanded; "Men to the left! Women to the right!'" That was the last moment Elie said he saw his mother and little sister, as they were forced right and Elie and his father were forced left. Then in the movie, the family arrives in the camp and the women all get out one side of the train, and men the other. Guido however, in a last attempt to see Dora (his wife) again, jumps on the train onto the other side as they look at each other as a final goodbye. The movie and the book are similar since both families are separated in similar fashion, how women were sent in one direction and men in the other.
The mood in these two works are very different. In Night Elie tells what he's feeling in his perspective. How he had seen so many dying around him, being moved from camp to camp. In the book he had said, "I too had become a different person. The student of Talmud, the child I was, had been consumed by the flames." This shows just how heavy the mood was during the whole duration of the book. While inside of the movie, Guido is trying to create a happy mood for his kid, since the child thinks the camp is a giant game. Guido like any good father, tries to hide all the horrors behind the camp and does anything to make his child smile. As to show how the mood in the movie was a lot lighter than Night as there was also a lot of comedy coming from Guido.
Both the movie and the book have very different points of views. For example, Elie and Guido are both Jewish, however Elie is the only one that practices the religion. I think that, that specific part is why the book was so suspenseful. How we as readers were able to see his transformation from the kid that loved to study and practice his religion, to a kid who questioned and disliked God. Its that much more suspenseful seeing as his religion used to be the most important thing in his life, so to be taken away so quickly meant that what he went through changed him probably faster than anything else in his life. In the movie however, Guido had never practiced the religion and continues his daily life. I think it had a bit more humor because of this, since loosing your faith is something huge. Guido still managed to make everyone laugh with his cheerful nature, which I think was another main reason as to why the movie was more humorous.
*SPOILERS*
One way I thought life was shown as beautiful throughout the film was Dora and Guido's love. Since we are all different, and we all have emotions its beautiful that people are lucky enough to enjoy having such a strong love like Dora and Guido had. For example how Guido risked his life, as his child's in order to send Dora a message on how he loved her and wanted to let her know they were both doing fine. Another way I thought life was shown as beautiful throughout the film was Guido's love to his kid. Every parent loves their kid, but Guido knew what he was getting into the moment he put his child into the box near the end of the movie. Guido was trying to hide his kid so that he could go find Dora, and even when he got caught, as soon as he started walking in front of the box, he was marching funny in order to try and cheer up his son. Even in his final moments, his main priority was to keep his soon happy, as the last memory the boy would ever have of him. I think that's how life is shown as beautiful because parents have the natural instinct to keep their kids safe and happy, and I think Guido did a wonderful job keeping his child safe before he was shot.
No comments:
Post a Comment